Bluegill - Big Bluegill

Do you love big bluegill?

I went on you tube looking at different knots, and found one called the 100% knot. I sometimes have trouble seeing my 2 and 4 lb. test when I tie a improved clinch knot, and thought I would try something easier on my eyes. I lost two fish today because of knot failure. I finally just squinted hard, and went back to the improved clinch knot. Has anyone else on here tried this knot?

Views: 2558

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

100% failure knot. Perfect for usage on 10lbs or more. Not so much on 6lbs and less. I practice on my nail knot. Got it down packed without thr use of an aid after a few months of playing with it. So far, my nail knot surpasses all my other knots. Improved clinch knot when i'm in a hurry. Nail knot when I have a bit of luxury multitasking time.

I haven't tried the knot you speak of, have never heard of it, but I'll offer what I tie, which is the Palomar knot.  I switched from the improved clinch over thirty years ago to the Palomar; it's a vastly superior knot, and pretty simple to tie.  

One other resource for knots - North American Fishing Club has an ongoing comparison of knots they do called "knot wars;" I've seen it a couple times on TV, and they have some pretty impressive knots that they've tested.  If I recall correctly, they have all of the knots that have done well in the tests, listed on their website.  

But I rarely, rarely ever have a Palomar give way.

I've used the improved clinch every since I can remember. I do like the Palomar but I feel like I loose to much line by the time I get it tied and cut the tag end off. Lionheart you will have to show me the Nail Knot I'm not familiar with it.

Nail knot is slightly tricky to master just by hand without an aid of a nail, or normally use an empty ink pen reservoir tube since it's smaller and easier to tighten up without making a messy knot. Try YouTube and search for a nail knot. Quite fun to play with. Since it has no tightening to create a crease in the line, there's minimal to no damage to the line that may cause a line failure. I have yet lost a fish due to knot slippage, whether be fly, flouro, or mono.

I have exactly that problem, too. I've been tying the improved clinch since childhood and I always forget the Palomar and have to look it up again if I want to use it :p No knot is worse than the one you can't remember, so I always fall back to the improved clinch.

I've got that eye problem, too. I've been nearsighted since my late teens, which usually gives excellent reading-distance vision as a side effect, but now I can't focus on things that are too near my eyes, either. Of course, when 4 pound line is far enough away to see, it's too far away to see <g>

The "Nail Knot" is commonly used in fly-fishing to tie backing to fly line, and leader to fly line.

Surprising, it's also the same knot in the store-bought, pre-tied bobber stops that come on little plastic tubes.  The tube serves the same purpose as the nail.

Amen on the seeing part I feel your pain.

The improved clinch knot sucks as does the regular clinch knot. The very best knot to tie for bluegill and most fisherman using a regular hook, is the original snell knot. There's a problem though, it's one of the toughest knots to learn BUT once mastered, it's THE BEST KNOT out there. It's been around forever and was originally developed and utilized in deep sea fishing.

 

It took me a while to master the Snell but trust me, it's worth the effort and frustration. It allows more in-line hookups with fish too, meaning you'll miss less. This is coming from a knot expert, I can tie several hundred knots in various situations. I can make a life rescue contraption out of a French Bowline, Double Bowline or Spanish Bowline. I've always had a keen interest in knots because my Grandpa was a Navy man in WW11 and he could tie many knots.

The type of fishing line you are using will have a big impact on which knot you should use. Mono, braid, and flurocarbon all have some knots that work well, while others do not.

Flurocarbon in particular.

Tony don't know exactly what you mean. I have about 15UL rod & reel combo's and on 90% of them I use fluorocarbon and my go to knot is the improve clinch and don't ever recall loosing a fish because of the knot. That's not to say I've never lost a fish using fluorocarbon but the fault is my own I know you have to retie on occasion when I get nicks in my line but sometimes I get a little lacks and don't and have paid the price for being lazy. But all in all the improve clinch has served me well.

My experience was with P-line's fluroclear, a flurocarbon coated line. I can't begin to recall the number of fish I broke off due to a weak knot. It simply didn't have very good knot strength with an improved clinch. It would do better with a palomar, but still gave up too easily.  I went back to my trusted Sufix Elite, and haven't lost another fish since.

I'm sticking with mono from now on.

Tony, I too use mono, and never even consider fishing with a bargain brand (P-line, etc.).  Twenty or so years ago when braided first made a resurgence, I tried some of the braided lines, but didn't like them - they're much less supple than mono, as is fluorocarbon.  I think they're a good choice for bass fishing when heavier line is used, but for bluegill fishing with light line, mono is where it's at.

I don't know if I've ever tried Sufix - how does it compare to Trilene XL?  The latter is the best mono I've used.  I've been wanting to try some of the Yo-Zuri hybrid line, and the Nashville Bass Pro carries it but the smallest size they have is 10-lb.  But I would think since it's part fluorocarbon that it would probably be too stiff in 6-lb., which is what I use.

RSS

Latest Activity

John Sheehan commented on John Sheehan's photo
Thumbnail

SQUIRREL TAIL JIGS2023

"Bruce -The Black Ice Dub might work nicely. Ripple Ice Dub | Ole Florida Fly Shop "
17 hours ago
John Sheehan commented on John Sheehan's photo
Thumbnail

SQUIRREL TAIL JIGS2023

"Dick the closest colors I found for Flash is the Grey Ghost, which I think I have,…"
17 hours ago
John Sheehan commented on John Sheehan's photo
Thumbnail

SQUIRREL TAIL JIGS2023

"Nice ideas Dick and Bruce .I'll have to try them ."
17 hours ago
Bruce Tomaselli commented on John Sheehan's photo
Thumbnail

SQUIRREL TAIL JIGS2023

"You also could add a collar of black ice dub or a contrasting color of red or orange."
17 hours ago
dick tabbert commented on John Sheehan's photo
Thumbnail

SQUIRREL TAIL JIGS2023

"John I think they look great as they are. If they were mine I'd add just a little flash just…"
21 hours ago
John Sheehan commented on John Sheehan's photo
Thumbnail

SQUIRREL TAIL JIGS2023

"Dick what do you think would be good to add into these simple ties? "
yesterday
dick tabbert commented on John Sheehan's photo
Thumbnail

SQUIRREL TAIL JIGS2023

"Look Good. Nice job."
yesterday
John Sheehan commented on John Sheehan's photo
Thumbnail

SQIRREL TAIL JIGS2023

"Thanks Bruce! Simple ties, I'm not capable of much more. The Squirrel and Bucktails are…"
Saturday
Bruce Tomaselli commented on John Sheehan's photo
Thumbnail

SQIRREL TAIL JIGS2023

"Those look nice."
Friday
John Sheehan posted photos
Friday
John Sheehan replied to John Sheehan's discussion Ice Fishing Walleyes in the group WALLEYE
Nov 23
John Sheehan replied to John Sheehan's discussion Ice Fishing Walleyes in the group WALLEYE
"Seven Ice Fishing Tips For Jigging Walleyes With Spoons - Catch Cover"
Nov 21
John Sheehan commented on John Sheehan's group Targeting Golden Shiners
"Photos - Bluegill - Big Bluegill (ning.com)"
Nov 20
dick tabbert commented on dick tabbert's photo
Thumbnail

Fly tying leg

"Thanks Slip it's coming. My hardest part is getting pheasant tails with long enough fibers to…"
Nov 14
Slip Sinker commented on dick tabbert's photo
Thumbnail

Fly tying leg

"true art"
Nov 14
dick tabbert commented on dick tabbert's photo
Thumbnail

Fly tying leg

"A long way from science but better as we go.  Thanks Jim."
Nov 11
jim cosgrove commented on dick tabbert's photo
Thumbnail

Fly tying leg

"Looks like you got knotting those suckers down to a science.Good to see you tying again Dick,"
Nov 11
dick tabbert posted a photo

Fly tying leg

Legs made out of rubber and pheasant tails.
Nov 9
dick tabbert commented on John Sheehan's photo
Thumbnail

FIRST Bass 2023

"Nice Bass John."
Nov 9
John Sheehan commented on John Sheehan's album
Thumbnail

Best Fish 2023

"Hey Jeff -Of course 31 Fish and 6 doubles in the net was an epic in September for me and Greg! "
Nov 9

© 2023   Created by Bluegill.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service