Bluegill - Big Bluegill

Do you love big bluegill?

Here's something only my fevered mind would dream up.
Every angler wants to catch the big name fish. Big bass, Massive salmon, trophy bluegill, arapaima in South America (my personal quest), and so on.

But what about those other fish, the "trashy" ones we don't admire nor talk much about? If you were to target them, which ones would you go after?

In other words, what would a "Non-game Fish Bucket List" look like?

Views: 5470

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Def. snakehead. If we manage a family vacation to Florida in the next few years, I hope to be able to set a side a day with a guide to take me after snakehead. As Leo will attest, I'm sure, they're really tasty :-)

Haven't done much fishing this summer, though. Just got through a it of remodeling, and was further distracted by getting a Benjamin Marauder .25 :-)

Oh David! So many fish... so little time!

1. My current quest (not considered a trash fish by any means) a legal size (18") Saugeye on a fly rod.

2. Rio Grande Perch (Texas Cichlid) on a fly rod

3. Mountain Whitefish of double digit length... on a fly rod of course

4. 20+ pound carp on a fly

5. Mooneye/Goldeneye on a fly, double digit length would be gravy

6. Both an Oklahoma Chain Pickerel and an Oklahoma Grass Pickerel, fly rod would be great but ultra light spinning would work

7. A Sand (White) Bass as close to 5lbs as is humanly possible on a fly

8. A 2lbs Bluegill, a 2lbs Red Ear and a 2lbs Green Sunfish all in the same day. Fly rod, spinning gear, cane pole... don't care

9. 12"+ Red Spot Chub on a fly rod

10. Pirate Perch however possible

If I had to actually think about it I could come up with a dozen more. These are just the ones written on sticky notes over my fly tying bench.

#1 - Go to Shell Creek lake, NW of Sand Springs.  I know they're in there.

#4 - This is a pattern that works in the Spring, when the Cottonwood trees are dropping their fluff.....Go below Keystone Dam at night (probably any tailwater will do).  No generation!  Calm water.  The carp should come up top and start sucking down the Cottonwood fluff.  Tie some dry flies, probably size 12 or so, and tie some white CDC feathers to the hook.  Cast one out in front of a feeding carp (Keystone's tailrace has lights, so you can see).  When it gets sucked in, set the hook!

#5 - I have caught a Mooneye/Goldeye, but not on the fly.  I caught it on a jig. Probably a Clouser?  Don't ask me how to target them.  The one I caught was a fluke.....

#6 - You need to head to the SE part of the state.....

#7 - GOOD LUCK!!!  State-Record Sandie (over 5 lbs) was caught before genetic testing was done on the fish.  If you study the picture of the supposed record Sandie, it's actually a missidentified Hybrid Striper.

#8 - Bristow City lake!

  All this gar talk, hey they tear up your equipment, been there ,done that, but I have buddy that is moving into the sunken lands and is right across the road from a boat launch and I told him we would go for a boat ride on the river and the lake that was created the same day Reelfoot Lake was formed, during the New Madrid earthquake. Years ago people came from all over to fish for alligator gar and I know they are still in there so we may have to try our  luck, It's only 15 miles from the house, might be fun.  I had another buddy that had oscars in a fish tank,they looked tasty, anybody ever try one? LOFR

Are you talking about Caddo Lake???

Ever hear about the Caddo Lake Monster?

Allen the place I'm talking about is the St Francis River where in 1930 someone caught a 350 pound alligator gar, been in there several times and it looks like a swamp in South Louisiana    LOFR

gar is real popular around my area, fishing guides get top dollar to take folks out after the alligator gar. got one when i was about 12 on a rod and reel. didnt know what i had cranked him in like crazy till the splashes started. then i  leaned the rod back to bring him up toward me and next thing i knew a mouth full of teeth was coming my way. being a freaked out kid i let go of the whole rig, rod reel line hook and fish. i keep hearing about carp that get pretty hefty id like to hunt some down. 

Carp on on my bucket list . Red suckers get good sized around here in NENJ and here's a real good one I got that I enjoyed catching on 4# test . These two as they are around the waters I fish .Just gotta learn to target ,put the time in and catch them.

John...that's a pretty big one there. We have white suckers in our rivers. I once caught a 16 pound mirror carp while fishing for musky in the Potomac...fish was snagged in the tail with a Mepps spinner. I guess that one doesn't count! Ha Ha!

Wait........they make fish other than Bluegill???????

I've been slummin' it for years and have caught spotted gar, bowfin, white suckers, fallfish and quillback carpsuckers and others. I fished for snakeheads on Marylands Mattawoman Creek last summer and drew a blank, although there are now guides who ply these great largemouth waters with a good chance of a 'Potomac Pike', or snakehead, being caught while fishing for bass. The northern snakehead is firmly entrenched in Potomac tributaries below DC and fish to 18 pounds have been caught. They are reported to be better tasting than walleye, and spectacular fighters, with brilliant coloration.

Quite a fish!

RSS

Latest Activity

Jeffrey D. Abney commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Thumbnail

Nesting Pair of Ospreys......

"Yeah most nests are not this close to the water and this river is remote with alligators and large…"
2 hours ago
John Sheehan commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Thumbnail

Nesting Pair of Ospreys......

"Guess the Osprey knew it was a great spot too. The Cormorants up here are murder on the stocked…"
3 hours ago
Jeffrey D. Abney commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Thumbnail

Nesting Pair of Ospreys......

"This was a great fishing spot for me until the osprey nested……I’ve seen chicks…"
20 hours ago
Jeffrey D. Abney commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
20 hours ago
Jeffrey D. Abney commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Thumbnail

So many spots to place your bait...

"These cypress trees are now in the water….still producing great fishing…"
20 hours ago
Jeffrey D. Abney commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Thumbnail

The big Cypress downed by a Hurricane.....

"This is a good example John…..I posted this picture in 2012 and a couple weeks ago I caught…"
20 hours ago
John Sheehan commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
22 hours ago
Jeffrey D. Abney commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Thumbnail

Found a Few Hibiscus not Quite Bloomed…..7/5/2025

"Thanks John…..being in the south we’re always drawn to cypress trees and the…"
22 hours ago
John Sheehan commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Thumbnail

Found a Few Hibiscus not Quite Bloomed…..7/5/2025

"Nice info, Jeffrey! Up here my main Crappie habits have been wood cover near deep water and willow…"
yesterday
Jeffrey D. Abney commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Thumbnail

My Dad Doesn't know Where to Cast Next.......

"This is my dad who loved fishing…..this cove is similar to the one with all cattails but in…"
yesterday
Jeffrey D. Abney commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Thumbnail

Found a Few Hibiscus not Quite Bloomed…..7/5/2025

"I think all fresh water fish like to relate to cattails…..the most cattails I’ve ever…"
yesterday
John Sheehan commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Thumbnail

Found a Few Hibiscus not Quite Bloomed…..7/5/2025

"Up here the Pickerel can be found by Cattails and other tall reed areas. The first spawning…"
yesterday
Jeffrey D. Abney posted a photo

Found a Few Hibiscus not Quite Bloomed…..7/5/2025

This is always a great spot with cypress, cattails and now a blooming hibiscus..next time I’m there…
Saturday
Jeffrey D. Abney commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Thumbnail

Fish Attractant in the Coastal N.C. Marsh…..7/4/2025

"Thanks John…anytime you get close to them there’s hundreds of different insects…"
Saturday
Jeffrey D. Abney posted a photo

Joe Struck Copper on a Sand Bar….7/5/2025

The wind was building on the main river so we splashed back to the ramp after 42 gills, 1 bullhead…
Saturday
John Sheehan commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Thumbnail

Fish Attractant in the Coastal N.C. Marsh…..7/4/2025

"Good work on finding fish habitat!"
Saturday
Jeffrey D. Abney posted a photo

Pretty Masked Copper Shallow ……7/5/2025

Preparing for next week’s buck moon on 7/10……
Saturday
Jeffrey D. Abney posted photos
Saturday
Jeffrey D. Abney posted photos
Saturday
Jeffrey D. Abney posted a status
"Up early this morning, heard we were going to have a tropical storm in the Carolina’s…so Joe and I went and burned some crickets…"
Saturday

© 2025   Created by Bluegill.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service