Bluegill - Big Bluegill

Do you love big bluegill?

Before I get too far into making myself the town idiot, can I get clarification that these fish could all be females?





Views: 171

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

at a glance, the first and last appear to be males. The "ear" is more elongated.
Here's my guess, along with my percentage of certainty.

1. Female 70%
2. Female 100%
3. Female 100%
4. Female 100%
5. Female 70%

I think both the first and fifth fish have the potential to be immature males, or cuckolder males, but they look more like older, low Wr females. Probably 4-5 year old fish.

They have female coloration and no black scale tipping along the nape, which is indicative of males. To be honest with you, if I hadn't fileted about a thousand fish just like this, I would have probably guessed them as males.
I agree they all have the female coloration - and if I had to make a decisions M or F - I'd go F on all the pics.

The last picture to me is the one that I would question the most - I guss if I was harvesting males only or females only as part of a management plan - and I wasn't sure.................... I'd keep it and at least it couldn't really hurt in the long run.

FH
I agree fully with what Dr. Bruce said. If I were selecting males for a project none of them would be kept as definate male fish.
Thanks!

Here's the situation. This pond I'm fishing has been on it's own accord for ~12-13 years now. It's a private pond that recieves limited use from individuals that have access to it (IWLA membership only).
Over the past few weeks, the three of us (myself and two boys) have handled 132 'gills from our angling attempts - I can't ID any of them as being definate male fish.
This concerns me for the future of this pond.

I question if it's our angling techniques that may be limiting us to the female population - targetting certain areas at certain times of day, with a certain presentation; or has past removal of bull 'gills by the collective users started to show it's ugly head?
Zig - Since you are not catching BG with more distinct male characters, I think probably most of what you are seeing are the affects of anglers that have cropped or harvested the larger BG probably many from the spawning beds when mature BG are quite a bit more vulnerable to shoreline anglers. Control or management of a fishery is definately more difficult when other "free will" anglers are involved. Thus you are not fully aware of what comprises the fishery and what has been removed.

In some ponds/lakes the majority of BG do not get much larger than those you are catching. But when that occurs, male BG, when mature and the size in your photos, do have at least some of the "characteristic male features". One or two of those in your 4 photos could could easily be immature males. Dr. Bruce's and my comments were that none of them were positively mature male fish, and not that none were male fish. I just ment that none were definately males if I needed 99.99% assurance that the fish was male.

Zig mentions "I question if it's our angling techniques"...., This could have an influence at least with catching the largest, wiser BG. How big and maximum depth is the pond/small lake? Shoreline fishing sometimes does not reach the deeper refuge areas for larger fish. Sometimes later in summer and fall the larger BG stay more offshore and in deeper water, thus by not fishing where they are holding or hanging out can limit catches to smaller individuals. Sometimes when large BG are hook smart due to frequent fishing pressure, they will not bite baits presented in regular manner. One has to use finese techniques, often with live bait on small hooks on 2-4 lb test line fished (sometimes from a boat or tube float) in deeper water.
By carefully studying the markings on the fish in those pictures, I have determined that they are all pictures of the same individual fish. ;o)

That is one hungry and angry fish, now that you've caught it 132 times. Or maybe it just likes to be petted? LOL!

Just kidding!
Looks like all females by their coloration. Some fish can be classified by the shape of their anal openings. Males have a round hole while females have a pear shaped opening. I have used this on bass and muskie but not on bluegills yet. I can also age them by the rings on their scales somewhat like ageing a tree by the growth rings.

RSS

Latest Activity

dick tabbert commented on Bruce Tomaselli's photo
Thumbnail

foam bugs

"Great looking flies Bruce."
Saturday
Bruce Tomaselli commented on DAVID L EITUTIS's photo
Thumbnail

8/18/12

"I sure will. The baetis wet fly is a size 18 and the cicada is a size 8. Although I tied them for…"
Saturday
DAVID L EITUTIS commented on DAVID L EITUTIS's photo
Thumbnail

8/18/12

"WILL YOU POST PICS AGAIN OF YOUR WORK BRUCE? THANKS TOOTY"
Saturday
John Sheehan commented on Bruce Tomaselli's photo
Thumbnail

foam bugs

"Nice work ,Bruce!"
Saturday
Bruce Tomaselli commented on DAVID L EITUTIS's photo
Thumbnail

8/18/12

"I found it on YouTube, David. I'll be tying some for the upcoming crappie and bluegill spawn."
Friday
DAVID L EITUTIS commented on Bruce Tomaselli's photo
Thumbnail

foam bugs

"GREAT LOOKING BUGS BRUCE , BET YOU CATCH A BUNCH ON THOSE....."
Friday
DAVID L EITUTIS commented on DAVID L EITUTIS's photo
Thumbnail

8/18/12

"HEY BRUCE, IT'S TO HARD TO EXPLAIN HOW TO MAKE EM , BUT I HAVE SEVERAL VIDEO'S ON MAKING…"
Friday
Bruce Tomaselli commented on DAVID L EITUTIS's photo
Thumbnail

8/18/12

"They look like good crappie flies. Do you have a pattern to share for it? "
Friday
DAVID L EITUTIS commented on DAVID L EITUTIS's photo
Thumbnail

8/18/12

"HEY BRUCE , I USED TO for the first 20 or so years I used em.........now I have to tip em for some…"
Mar 5
Bruce Tomaselli commented on DAVID L EITUTIS's photo
Thumbnail

8/18/12

"Anyone every fish jigs, like the Silent Stingers, and catch fish without tipping them with waxies,…"
Mar 5
dick tabbert commented on DAVID L EITUTIS's photo
Thumbnail

8/18/12

"Nice"
Mar 4
Bruce Tomaselli commented on DAVID L EITUTIS's photo
Thumbnail

DSCN0020

"That's sure neat compared to mine."
Mar 3
John Sheehan commented on DAVID L EITUTIS's photo
Thumbnail

DSCN0020

"Great tying Space, Tooty!"
Mar 3
DAVID L EITUTIS joined bluegillboogieman's group
Thumbnail

HOW TO

A place to put explicit details of how to. Like how to remove a hook from your buddy's ear, or how…See More
Mar 2
dick tabbert commented on dick tabbert's photo
Thumbnail

GriffithsGnat1

"I hope you're right David. Ill let you know. I can say these were a strain on my eyes they…"
Mar 2
DAVID L EITUTIS commented on dick tabbert's photo
Thumbnail

GriffithsGnat1

"THESE ARE FANTASTIC LOOKING DICK........REAL  GILL GETTERS FOR SURE..."
Mar 2
dick tabbert posted a photo

GriffithsGnat1

Colors are orange, brown, and green.
Mar 2
DAVID L EITUTIS commented on DAVID L EITUTIS's photo
Thumbnail

8/18/12

"I STILL MAKE ALL THESE EXCEPT NOW ON # 8 HOOKS....."
Mar 2
DAVID L EITUTIS commented on DAVID L EITUTIS's photo
Thumbnail

DSCN0020

"THIS WAS THE FIRST PIC I POSTED ON HERE.....NOW I use # 8 HOOKS EXCLUSIVELY .....BOTH BEAD HEADS…"
Mar 2
DAVID L EITUTIS commented on DAVID L EITUTIS's photo
Thumbnail

DSCN0020

"FROM THE FIRST PIC I POSTED ON HERE I THINK......"
Mar 2

© 2025   Created by Bluegill.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service