Bluegill - Big Bluegill

Do you love big bluegill?

gillbum here,

John Gierach, one of our best contemporary fly/trout fishing writers, said in one of his 16 books, "the brook trout is prettier than it has to be." At least I think it was him who said it, and if it wasn't it should have been. John is also an ardent bluegill fisherman and writes about his pursuit of gills on a number of occasions. I've always felt that a statement like that could be said, and a case made, for several members of the sunfish family, too, in particular the bluegill and the pumpkinseed. Setting aside size and perhaps popularity, what say our little fly fishing group? Which is the prettiest sunfish, a male gill or a male seed, both in full spawning colors?

After decades of fishing for both, I personally, would give the edge to the pumpkinseed for color,with the gill running an extremely close second. I wonder how our little group would answer this? Remember, nothing counts in this little poll but prettiness or handsomeness, however you want to define it.

gb

Views: 3573

Replies to This Discussion

In my humble opinion, the pumpkinseed has more vivid coloration, but the bluegill has a very special ability to create individual and group variations. It's kinda like Forrest Gump when he said "Life is like a nest of male bluegills. You never know what you're gonna get".


Here in Oklahoma we have a little sunfish that rarely gets more than 3 inches long. A 4 incher is a "Wall Hanger" so to speak. It is the Orange Spotted Sunfish. In breeding colors it rivals what is generally thought of as the most colorful sunfish in these parts, the Long-eared Sunfish.

I don't know if any of you have these little guys around your fishing holes, but they can be shy at times. I usually catch them around large, stacked rocks, where they like to dart out and nab a small fly, then dash back into their hidey hole. They seem to hang around (under) boat ramps quite a bit as well.

They are rarely caught, and I think most anglers believe them to be small versions of better known fish.

They are great in an aquarium, and keep their colors well.

OkKeith
Dang, Keith! That's a beautiful fish! Can we get a bigger shot of that?
red spotted sunfish

By far the pertiest fish I ever caught. Normaly though. These fish are very bland. Kinda brown in color.

With a gill I think the beauty comes in catching it. The time spent with the kids, Parents, Friends, Family or just by yourself for a moment of peace and quite. Just like old married people most of us have spent better than 25years with em. No matter how they act or look they are still just like our spouse what has given us some of our best and worst memories over the years. But nomatter what people say about em.....We smile and keep on fishin em. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder. Ive never seen anyone not smile that was holdin a bluegill.

Lovin ole faithful,
Mayo
Mayo! You said it all, friend.

We've had a lot of amazing and beautiful sunfish photos on this site, but that picture of yours is the most remarkable. I've looked all over the internet for a similar photo and I can't find one.

RSS

Latest Activity

Jeffrey D. Abney commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Thumbnail

Always Calm Behind Heavy Thunderstorms…..6/17/2025

"Understand Bruce….live near a cabbage farmer and saw them picking them…"
34 minutes ago
Bruce Tomaselli commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Thumbnail

Always Calm Behind Heavy Thunderstorms…..6/17/2025

"We've had nothing but rain here in south-central, PA. The farmers can't plant and…"
12 hours ago
Bruce Tomaselli commented on John Sheehan's photo
Thumbnail

Colorado Spinner gets 3 species

"Nice, John. Is that a generic name or the name of the spinner?"
12 hours ago
John Sheehan posted a photo

Colorado Spinner gets 3 species

So far this year, this little cost-effective Colorado spinner has gotten many a Bluegill as well as…
yesterday
Jeffrey D. Abney posted photos
yesterday
Jeffrey D. Abney posted a status
"Got a window this morning after all the storms the last four days…water falling on the coastal marsh was a beneficial thing with the crappie"
yesterday
John Sheehan commented on John Sheehan's photo
Thumbnail

Wanaque river Trout

"Thanks Guys,a leaper from the fast water always excites!"
yesterday
Jeffrey D. Abney commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Thumbnail

Good Shoulders. On this One….6/12/2025

"Thanks wag….I imagine the summer heat has set in down in Louisiana!"
yesterday
wag commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
yesterday
Jeffrey D. Abney commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Monday
Jeffrey D. Abney commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Thumbnail

Tagging Black Crappie on Shallow Wood…..6/12/2025

"Thanks Dick…..got a few areas that remain productive for shallow crappie… never…"
Monday
Jeffrey D. Abney commented on John Sheehan's photo
Thumbnail

Ducks in the shade Wanaque river

"Always enjoy nature when I get out…."
Monday
Jeffrey D. Abney commented on John Sheehan's photo
Thumbnail

Wanaque river Trout

"Good job with the Colorado spinner….."
Monday
Jeffrey D. Abney commented on John Sheehan's photo
Thumbnail

Wanaque river Crappie

"Nice crappie….I like seeing the old school baits…."
Monday
dick tabbert commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Thumbnail

Tagging Black Crappie on Shallow Wood…..6/12/2025

"Looks like the crappie bite is on."
Sunday
dick tabbert commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Sunday
dick tabbert commented on John Sheehan's photo
Sunday
dick tabbert commented on John Sheehan's photo
Thumbnail

Wanaque river Crappie

"John, nice looking crappie."
Sunday
John Sheehan posted photos
Sunday
Jeffrey D. Abney posted a photo

Good Shoulders. On this One….6/12/2025

This was a fun day…..80 black crappie dominated this party…
Jun 12

© 2025   Created by Bluegill.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service