Bluegill - Big Bluegill

Do you love big bluegill?

Big Bluegill in Goose Creek, S.C. - Am I remembering them correctly?

Hello folks. I'm new here, and thought I'd start with a question about bluegills in the Goose Creek, just outside of Charleston, S.C.

Long ago and far away, ('72-ish)I was stationed at the sub base at Charleston. Often I would hang around the boat launch on Goose Creek watching the old men come in off the creek in the waning hours of daylight. I saw some big stringers of BIG fish. I could have sworn they were dinner plate sized. I was a long way from home, and really wanted one of those old fellas to invite me to go fishing with them, but it was the Viet Nam era, and there wasn't much more reviled in a Navy town than a sailor. In fact, were it not for my persistence, they wouldn't have even acknowledged my existence.

Here's the deal: I was recently fishing in a friend's farm pond in north central Missouri, and caught some bluegill that I thought were "nice", but nothing to 'write home about'. They were just over 9" long and weighed just at a pound. Nice fish no doubt, but not exactly 'braggers'. However, my friend and his neighbors practically wanted to notify the newspapers! "Biggest fish caught around here since anyone can remember"...

And here are the questions: Are those truly "big" bluegills? Am I remembering the ones from Goose Creak with the "eye of a fisherman"? Were they really likely only a pound or so? I would have sworn that they were at least two pounds, and maybe three! However, when I look on line for state records, I don't see any 3 lb bluegills. 

I would appreciate a "reality check" from any of y'all that fish that creek, or are familiar with it and the fish (and gators!) that inhabit it.

Thanks,

Paul

Views: 1521

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

And these were caught in public, open waters?
I ask because I usually think of hybrids as BRED fish. Of course they can hybridize naturally, but it's my understanding that's as a result of pressure, i.e., crowding, habitat loss, etc.
I'm probably wrong; Tony gets me all the one with my foot in my mouth. But it seems a dream come true to find massive, overweight hybrids like this in a naturally competitive environment.

No, these were caught in a private farm pond. My original post referenced a faded memory, most likely of red-breasted, not bluegills.

I agree that these look like "pure-bred" bluegills to me, but looks can sometimes be deceiving.

You can take my word on the weights or not. I have nothing to prove. In fact,my initial comments were remarking how much these DIDN'T weigh.

Paul

Okay, I see my confusion.
I couldn't wrap my mind around these recently pictured fish and those one might see knocking around a boat ramp.
No offense intended.

None taken.

Paul

so I guess that's where the phrase;; perch jerker came from..  that's a jerk on one end of the line;; waiting on a jerk from the other end !!  LOL!!

Panfishing, in general, is not the main course in many parts of the 'back east' or Mid Atlantic. Crappie have a strong following, but few anglers routinely target bluegills in my Mason Dixon region. Many of the better venues are small, and vulnerable to overharvest. Maryland has a 15 fish per angler, per day regulation on bluegills. This works for great fisheries like Deep Creek Lake and smaller public lakes, but a 'one size fits all' harvest limit is seldom the answer for larger geographical regions.

I have been blessed to have found both public and private venues that have quality, and quantity bluegilling. Great fishing can be found in Delaware and Marylands Eastern Shore publicly managed millponds, to include trophy fish in some waters.

Like most fishing scenarios, the real 'fanatics' of a particular specie will search far and wide and put in lots of time for their prefered specie.

No different here, Jim. Most "serious" anglers go for brim when they're bedding; "We tore em up on the beds!" is a common phrase in May.
But the rest of the time they're too hard to catch and everybody goes for bass and crappie. Hardcore Southern types switch to night fishing for cats in summer. I'm slacking this year; I haven't hit the cat banks yet.

RSS

Latest Activity

Jeffrey D. Abney posted photos
yesterday
Jeffrey D. Abney replied to Jeffrey D. Abney's discussion Panfish Species of North America- Which Ones Have You Caught?
"Some quality Warmouth I caught in my early years on the Albemarle….."
yesterday
Jeffrey D. Abney replied to Jeffrey D. Abney's discussion Panfish Species of North America- Which Ones Have You Caught?
yesterday
Jeffrey D. Abney replied to Jeffrey D. Abney's discussion Panfish Species of North America- Which Ones Have You Caught?
yesterday
Jeffrey D. Abney posted photos
yesterday
Jeffrey D. Abney replied to Jeffrey D. Abney's discussion Panfish Species of North America- Which Ones Have You Caught?
"Thanks for sharing John……you have patterned your available species pretty good over…"
yesterday
John Sheehan replied to Jeffrey D. Abney's discussion Panfish Species of North America- Which Ones Have You Caught?
"Only caught five of these Species up here in New Jersey. Bluegill, Pumpkinseed, Red Breasted…"
yesterday
Jeffrey D. Abney posted a photo

Crackers Saved This Morning Behind A Cold Front…..7/23/2025

If I get out the remainder of July it will probably be a crappie stalk on the coastal marsh……
yesterday
Jeffrey D. Abney posted photos
yesterday
Jeffrey D. Abney posted photos
yesterday
Jeffrey D. Abney posted a status
"Slow Moving Cold Front Went Through Overnight and Shifted the Wind to the North so our rivers were dumped, but we wanted to go anyway…."
yesterday
Jeffrey D. Abney replied to Jeffrey D. Abney's discussion Panfish Species of North America- Which Ones Have You Caught?
Tuesday
Jeffrey D. Abney replied to Jeffrey D. Abney's discussion Panfish Species of North America- Which Ones Have You Caught?
"There’s multiple variations in the Spotted Sunfish….in Louisiana the Red Spotted…"
Tuesday
Jeffrey D. Abney replied to Jeffrey D. Abney's discussion Panfish Species of North America- Which Ones Have You Caught?
"Growing up in Louisiana into a fishing family I got many introductions to the Sportsman’s…"
Tuesday
Jeffrey D. Abney replied to Jeffrey D. Abney's discussion Panfish Species of North America- Which Ones Have You Caught?
"I have personally caught 11 of the 12 panfish featured in this discussion. I have never lived in…"
Tuesday
Jeffrey D. Abney posted a discussion
Tuesday
Jeffrey D. Abney posted photos
Monday
Jeffrey D. Abney posted photos
Monday
DAVID L EITUTIS commented on DAVID L EITUTIS's photo
Thumbnail

THIS COLOR COMBINATION SEEMS TO WORK THIS YEAR

"Yup blue and white is an essential with my oldest son......."
Monday
Jeffrey D. Abney posted a status
"My glass boat is going to the shop tomorrow, need an ignition system tune up, figured I would give it up during this extended heat wave.."
Sunday

© 2025   Created by Bluegill.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service