Bluegill - Big Bluegill

Do you love big bluegill?

All the talk about recipes lately has me excited. I was really intrigued by the mustard wrap idea and Ritz crackers sound great. But I felt, well, like the Lone Ranger with my suggestion to soak fish in 7UP prior to cooking.

For what its worth, I got a similar reaction at home. No one at my house really fancies freshwater fish - even I'm not a HUGE fan. But the gang thought I had lost my mind when I told them 7UP would make fish taste better. I assured them it was legit, but they looked at me like I had mushrooms growing in my ear. So, today, I did a little blind taste test.

I cooked some fish filets- tilapia - which we had on hand in the freezer. It needed to be eaten, anyway, so I used that.

1. One half of the fish was soaked in WalMart brand lemon-lime soda pop for 12-15 minutes. The other wasn't.

2. Both were dipped in egg wash and rolled in the same meal preparation.

3. Each was cooked in the same oil.

4. Each looked the same when finished.

Then I separated the samples and the volunteers (my sons) tasted some of each. I didn't tell them I had done anything special; as far as anyone knew, it was just fish.

On my part, I noticed an immediate difference in the taste - the soft drink soaked fish was noticeably milder. As I expected.

My sons were surprised, however. They could tell that one was milder than the other; it lacked a "fishy" taste, according to them. I revealed that those were "soda pop fish" - the same stuff they laughed at before.

I just wanted to share this. I'm certain the longer you soak the fish, the greater the effect. That will be the next experiment. This should be just the ticket for gamey, weedy flavored fish like bullheads, large cats, grinnell, summer bass and so on.

Views: 9185

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

David, we have soaked our rough, or strong fish in 7UP for years. You are correct on the extended soaking time having a greater effect. When I was a kid we would take the biggest river catfish and soak them overnight. Not only did they NOT taste strong, they had very little taste at all. Bland would be an appropriate description.

My family settled on 6 hours as being about right, at least where larger catfish were concerned.

I find that Tilapia has a very mild flavor to begin with.  I'll bet you're right for not soaking it any longer than 15 minutes.

Thanks, Tony.

Im not keen on "fishy" as a taste, and in my experience, freshwater fish always has it to some degree. Even tilapia makes me reach for the hushpuppies after a few bites. Knowing this simple trick has always helped me like fish more, making it a winner in my book. I may have to buy lemon-lime by the case! I wonder how it would work for freezing fish.

That it will work on most any fish - and the longer the better - also pleases me. some would not agree, but bland" as a taste for fish works, IMHO. I'm thinking the mustard wrap might have a similar effect.

Thanks for your reassuring words.

I only use 7up for larger strong tasting fish suck as salmon, steelhead and brown trout. I find bluegil, crappie and perch don need to be soaked. But it is very common and works very well. :)

Interesting you should say that. I have YET to find anyone who has heard of it. So far I get the same reaction my family had....

"Errr, excuse me - are those mushrooms growing from your ear? For a minute, David, it sounded like you said '7UP.'"

I'll try it with everything, this year. We shall see. BTW, where did you learn of it?

RSS

Latest Activity

John Sheehan commented on John Sheehan's status
"We are exploring/learning the three permit lakes late in life. Today was Canistear Reservoir. Hot…"
yesterday
John Sheehan posted a status
"Just dink smallmouths and Largemouth Bass for Greg and I, fishing a third Reservoir this year."
yesterday
John Sheehan posted photos
Tuesday
Bruce Tomaselli commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Thumbnail

Sunrise Shellcracker…..7/23/2025

"I love your kind of fishing!"
Sunday
Jeffrey D. Abney commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Thumbnail

Sunrise Shellcracker…..7/23/2025

"I’m very fortunate that the fishing  in coastal North Carolina is so great and most…"
Sunday
Jeffrey D. Abney commented on John Sheehan's photo
Thumbnail

JULYWP

"Summer colors on this white perch!"
Sunday
Jeffrey D. Abney commented on John Sheehan's photo
Thumbnail

JULYP

"Nice Yellow John….good colors"
Sunday
Jeffrey D. Abney replied to Jeffrey D. Abney's discussion Panfish Species of North America- Which Ones Have You Caught?
"Often bass fisherman will catch Warmouth on 9” worms……..they. don’t fight…"
Sunday
Jeffrey D. Abney replied to Jeffrey D. Abney's discussion Panfish Species of North America- Which Ones Have You Caught?
"This is a great comparison John…..I added another photo to give perspective….."
Sunday
Bruce Tomaselli commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Thumbnail

Sunrise Shellcracker…..7/23/2025

"I sure envy you, enjoy!"
Sunday
John Sheehan replied to Jeffrey D. Abney's discussion Panfish Species of North America- Which Ones Have You Caught?
"Hey Jeffrey! Does the Warmouth have about the same sized Mouth as a Black Crappie of equal size, or…"
Saturday
Jeffrey D. Abney posted photos
Jul 23
Jeffrey D. Abney replied to Jeffrey D. Abney's discussion Panfish Species of North America- Which Ones Have You Caught?
"Some quality Warmouth I caught in my early years on the Albemarle….."
Jul 23
Jeffrey D. Abney replied to Jeffrey D. Abney's discussion Panfish Species of North America- Which Ones Have You Caught?
Jul 23
Jeffrey D. Abney replied to Jeffrey D. Abney's discussion Panfish Species of North America- Which Ones Have You Caught?
Jul 23
Jeffrey D. Abney posted photos
Jul 23
Jeffrey D. Abney replied to Jeffrey D. Abney's discussion Panfish Species of North America- Which Ones Have You Caught?
"Thanks for sharing John……you have patterned your available species pretty good over…"
Jul 23
John Sheehan replied to Jeffrey D. Abney's discussion Panfish Species of North America- Which Ones Have You Caught?
"Only caught five of these Species up here in New Jersey. Bluegill, Pumpkinseed, Red Breasted…"
Jul 23
Jeffrey D. Abney posted a photo

Crackers Saved This Morning Behind A Cold Front…..7/23/2025

If I get out the remainder of July it will probably be a crappie stalk on the coastal marsh……
Jul 23
Jeffrey D. Abney posted photos
Jul 23

© 2025   Created by Bluegill.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service