Bluegill - Big Bluegill

Do you love big bluegill?

Here's a much better photo of the GIANT Redear right after she was caught. It looks like he may have been bait fishing, by the looks of those rod holders in the boat. She
measured 17" long and had a girth of 19.5"!

Rating:
  • Currently 5/5 stars.

Views: 991

Comment

You need to be a member of Bluegill - Big Bluegill to add comments!

Join Bluegill - Big Bluegill

Comment by Tony Livingston on February 19, 2014 at 1:46pm

Hmmm......Was this fish participating in a management plan of any sort, Carl?? If so, I would probably fall over in a slump, weep despondently, and rend my garments while pouring ashes on my head. The exact same things I might do if the fish came from an unmanaged BOW. ;)

Comment by carl hendrix on February 19, 2014 at 1:16pm

well-- lets have some fun on the reverse side!  WHAT IF!!!  you hooked one like this;;   got it to the boat;; reached out; with either hand or net;;   you see what a monster gill  it is;;  and in a flash-- it flips - twists- and gets  UNHOOKED!!  seeing your trophy -- slowly swimming away;; and as a gesture- from the giant gill-- flips its tail at you and splashes you in the face!!  as if to say-- im not that easy big guy!!   LORD OF THE FLYRODS  a little help here; if you don't mind your lordship;; put it in a more poetic way!!!!

Comment by David, aka, "McScruff" on February 19, 2014 at 12:23pm
But, I like thinking! (It does make my head hurt, though).

Okay, nice fish.
Comment by Tony Livingston on February 19, 2014 at 11:53am

There ya go Tooty!... I couldn't agree more. A trophy is a trophy, irregardless. There shouldn't be varying degrees of "trophydom"

I would love to have the chance to fish Havasu, even if I didn't tie into a biggun.

Well done Hector!!

Comment by DAVID L EITUTIS on February 19, 2014 at 11:36am

PEOPLE JUST PLAIN THINK TOO MUCH!!!!!!! GREAT FISH IN ANY CIRCUMSTANCE AND I DON'T CARE IF THEY ARE FEEDING EM STEROIDS !!!! ANY WAY YA SLICE IT , IT ALWAYS COMES OUT THE SAME. "TROPHY" ...........

Comment by Tony Livingston on February 19, 2014 at 10:26am

Alright, for the sake of discussion I offer up the following:

It appears that the sticking point revolves around an action being either deliberate, or accidental. I pose the following questions, and ask that they be reviewed carefully, and answered honestly.

1) Hypothetically speaking......it becomes known that the Quagga mussel infestation was not in fact an accident, but was a deliberate action performed by someone "in the know" regarding shellcrackers, and their food preferences. Now, what is the opinion of these giant, public water redears?

2) Hypothetically speaking....the circumstances as we now understand them remain the same, (accidental introduction of quagga's, etc), but havasu is not a public BOW, but a private lake inaccessible to the general public. What say you now? Is the catch still worthy of the same level of admiration, even if the person who caught it is the only guy allowed to fish there?

I think there could be an element we haven't touched on up until this point. It seems to me that a lot may be overlooked and forgiven, if the BOW in question is open to everyone irregardless of management or lack thereof.

Comment by David, aka, "McScruff" on February 19, 2014 at 10:03am

"It doesn't matter if the plant was introduced intentionally, or the quagga mussels accidentally, both are a form of management, and both are a one-time deal."

I'll have to disagree in the main. Accidental introduction is NOT management.

It produces an effect, yes.

And it can BE managed after the fact.

But if it is not done by design, then the two variables - fish and mussels - musn't be said to be part of a managed scheme.

"...the inescapable conclusion is that those fish would not be growing to these sizes had man not become involved."

You are 100% right, here. If we want to grind this down to its' finest point (and don't we LOVE to?), it is the ACTIVITIES of man that have had this serendipitous effect. Since every card game is a deliberate affair, that is as far as "the hand of man" card can be played here.

"Deliberate," is the operative concept. Since the mussels were not deliberately introduced for the purpose of creating a particular effect - big red ear, in this instance - we must only go so far as to call it a happy accident. Will there now be a deliberate program at Havasu to ensure a steady stream of these leviathans?

It has happened elsewhere....

(I still suspect Galbraiths of having a farm tank out back and a secret enclosure in the lake, nearby....LOL)

Comment by Tony Livingston on February 19, 2014 at 9:42am

"Agreed. A fish not "managed" to a purpose is another thing altogether."

I'll buy that. Now suppose we take this to it's next hypothetical step.....having a lake that produces world record redears is bound to be good for business, tourism and fishing related. Recognizing the fact that those record fish exist strictly due to an unforseen chain of events, (quagga mussels and weed eradication), the powers that be decide that weed eradication needs to be performed more aggressively, and regularly, in the hopes of continuing the string of giant fish.

Now where do we stand? Now they are managing for those giant redears, not by feeding, but by manipulating their environment in a fashion to hopefully allow things to continue on as they were.

Managing, is far more than throwing food out regularly. Take Tilapia for example. They're vegetarians, grazers. Say I introduce a particular plant into the water, and this plant reproduces itself and feeds all my tilapia, without me ever having to add any further feed of any kind. Is this management, even though it was a one time effort on my part? Yes it is.

It doesn't matter if the plant was introduced intentionally, or the quagga mussels accidentally, both are a form of management, and both are a one-time deal.

Those redears grew large due to an accident, and an intentional action. Neither was orchestrated for the benefit of the redears, but the inescapable conclusion is that those fish would not be growing to these sizes had man not become involved.

Comment by David, aka, "McScruff" on February 19, 2014 at 9:31am

"I would wager that a truly natural fish would be pretty hard to come by....a fish untouched in any fashion by the hand of man."

Agreed, 100%.

A fish not "managed," however, in a cloistered, closed environment as part of a determined and purposeful result.... well that is another thing altogether. Those we CAN come by.

In this case, that is NOT what we are seeing. And that was my point, at least.

Comment by Tony Livingston on February 19, 2014 at 8:58am

How did the mussels get into Havasu? Those cards that mother nature is playing were dealt by the hand of man....

What about where you fish LOFR? Were your waters, or are your waters, ever stocked with forage? (minnows, shad, etc)  And what about the weedkill at Havasu that enabled those RES to feed on the mussels....that wasn't natural either.

It doesn't matter if you zip open a bag of fishfood, or add a biological source of forage...either way you are manipulating the environment, altering the environment, managing the environment. I would wager that a truly natural fish would be pretty hard to come by....a fish untouched in any fashion by the hand of man.

Latest Activity

wag replied to Danny Phillips's discussion Boats
" Sold 17 ft and bought a 2017 Xpress 16 ft front stick steer with 40 hp Yamaha ob.  "
Wednesday
Jeffrey D. Abney commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Thumbnail

Big Sow Full of Eggs….3/30/2025

"Understand John….we were so windy in March ……..hope it drops off…"
Tuesday
John Sheehan commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Thumbnail

Big Sow Full of Eggs….3/30/2025

"I have yet to see 50 degree WT and it's too windy today."
Tuesday
Jeffrey D. Abney commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Thumbnail

Big Sow Full of Eggs….3/30/2025

"Always welcome…….I waited 16 days to go from 50 to 60 on this river….its a…"
Monday
John Sheehan commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Thumbnail

Big Sow Full of Eggs….3/30/2025

"Great intel, Jeff! Thanks!"
Monday
Jeffrey D. Abney commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Thumbnail

Big Sow Full of Eggs….3/30/2025

"Not in my region Dick….typically our shallow crappie bite centers around the March full…"
Monday
Jeffrey D. Abney commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Thumbnail

Nice Predator up Shallow….3/30/2025

"Thanks Dick…..the Bassmasters Elite series comes to town for the North Carolina open next…"
Monday
Jeffrey D. Abney commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Monday
dick tabbert commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Thumbnail

Big Sow Full of Eggs….3/30/2025

"Jeffrey don't it seam like the crappy bite is a little early?"
Monday
dick tabbert commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Thumbnail

Nice Predator up Shallow….3/30/2025

"A great test for any panfish gear. Congrats."
Monday
dick tabbert commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Monday
dick tabbert commented on Troy Dorman's photo
Monday
Bruce Tomaselli commented on Troy Dorman's photo
Monday
John Sheehan commented on Troy Dorman's photo
Thumbnail

Big male redear from today!!

"Fine Fish1From shore also!"
Monday
Jeffrey D. Abney commented on Troy Dorman's photo
Thumbnail

Big male redear from today!!

"Pretty Troy…..let’s go!"
Sunday
Troy Dorman posted a photo
Sunday
Jeffrey D. Abney posted photos
Sunday
Jeffrey D. Abney posted photos
Sunday
Jeffrey D. Abney posted photos
Sunday
Jeffrey D. Abney posted a status
"Grandson Cody and I splashed this afternoon…mixed bag of 38 fish dominated by shallow black crappie…surface temperatures up to 66.2 degrees"
Sunday

© 2025   Created by Bluegill.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service