Do you love big bluegill?
Help ID These
I took the kayak to an "out-of-the-way" lake in N.E. Michigan today in search of bluegills. I had never fished this lake so didn't know what to expect. Didn't get a single bluegill or pumpkinseed. I did get quite a few of the fish like the one in the first attached picture. At first I thought these were green sunfish but now I'm not so sure after doing some research online. The fish in the second attachment is one on which I am totally clueless. It measured 10", was very dark in color, and fought like a large bass. Both species had large mouths, much larger than gills or pumpkinseeds.
Let me know what you think they are.
Views: 423
- Attachments:
-
-
IMG_20150916_120532730.jpg, 2.2 MB -
IMG_20150916_123739979.jpg, 2.3 MB
-
Replies to This Discussion
-
Permalink Reply by Jeffrey D. Abney on
-
Nice fish Steve....looks to be hybrids to me but the experts will weigh in and help you out........
-
Permalink Reply by Slip Sinker on
-
Steve nice fish by the way! im guessing but im no expert
i believe the first fish is a hybrid. more p'seed than anything... im thinking p'seed x green sunfish
second fish i believe is green sunfish and at 10" is a master angler for michigan congrats
-
Permalink Reply by Stephen Ermak on
-
I was thinking the same about the first fish....a cross between pumpkinseed and green sunfish. The majority (95%) of the fish I caught that day were of this variety. So I'm left wondering, where were all the green sunfish and pumpkinseeds? If fish 2 is a green sunfish, then i caught only 2 of those that day. I didn't catch any pumpkinseeds. Once a population of pumpkinseed/green sunfish hybrids get established, can they continue to breed more hybrids like themselves and eventually force out the "purebreads"???
-
-
is this lake have a DNR access site or is it private... i wonder if it has stocking data on it. most of the time i see private lake owners association manage their fish selection and is popular to stock hybrids for more control for numbers.
-
-
The lake does not have an access site nor is it private. It is on National Forest land and there is a path to the lake from a nearby dirt road. I'm going to try it again tomorrow and see what else I can learn about what lives in there.
Latest Activity
cupsaw bass
"The Yellow Perch Pattern is more so a Northern catcher I believe, Jeff. The Silver /Black Back and…"
"Scattered thunderstorms predawn moved out to sea and I gave it a shot..North Carolina creeks/river were very dirty from runoff, moved north"
"Hoping the beat the frontal boundary tomorrow morning for a crappie stalk on the coastal marsh….we have a lot of uncertainty in our weather"
cupsawlow waterwalleye
"Nice adjustment to the conditions John……good fishing…..cool that you tied the…"
cupsawlow waterwalleye
"Hey Jeff-Every 4 years or so the lake committee lowers the lake for folks to do dock repairs. Thats…"
cupsawlow waterwalleye
"In a drought or drawdown for damn work? Nice fish…..I’ve never caught one but always…"
cupsaw bass
"I loved this bait color as a child…..but after lots of torture from being out fished by my…"
"Finally got a calm morning on the 19 day of September, a coastal low dumped rain and high winds promising to turn the marsh over and it did."
"Very rough weather pattern, ready to get out if the wind will break…all the creeks are blown out and holding low….had a good dinner tonight…"
© 2025 Created by Bluegill.
Powered by
