Bluegill - Big Bluegill

Do you love big bluegill?

Well, I had never done it before, but today I decided to try tipping my 1/64th oz shad dart jighead with two different baits to see if it would make a difference. I fished a small public lake in Adams County, PA from 3 to 5 pm. Weather was splendid...68 degrees and partly sunny skies and calm and the fish were biting.

Last week I had to go to the drop-shot/live worm rig to catch fish that had settled near the bottom of 6-8 feet of water after a cold front. Not today, as I found fish 5 ft from the surface over a submerged creek bed. Using the jig with a small piece of garden worm, I caught fish steadily until I reached a count of 19 fish, then decided to try the Gulp! minnows as a tipping bait. Since the entire 1 inch minnow would make a bulky, oversized offering for the gills, I decided to use the back half of the minnow as a tipping option, suspended just like the jig/worm option. Here are the results...The first three fish I caught on the Gulp minnow tipped jig were the three largest of the day at 10 to 10.5 inches. I don't know why this is, maybe a small group of bigger fish just cruised in at this particular time, but the top three were on successive casts. Maybe the jig and Gulp presented a slightly larger offering that only the bigger fish would approach...just a guess.

I caught the same amount...19 apiece...on each tipping option for a total of 38 released fish. Most of the fish on the Gulp tipping were 9 inches or better, and the worm offering fish were just slightly smaller. I fished each option for one hour.

Worm fish tended to take the bobber under with more gusto, and would make the bobber dissapeer. The fish that took the Gulp tipped jig tended to 'trail off' with the jig, not always pulling the bobber below the surface. Sometimes, they would just 'tilt' the bobber and you had to be able to recognize the strike. Most fish were caught over the creek channel, which is easy casting distance from the shoreline.

So what did I find out? Probably, not much. The fish were on the feed as a warm 70 degree November day had them going and action seemed just as fast with either bait. Water was at 56 degrees and clear. The only noticable differences was the 'trailing off' bites on the Gulp and the larger fish on same. Need to experiment more...maybe this Saturday at another lake!

No, didn't prove much today, except it was a beautiful time to be out and those lovely fish made it a great time.

Views: 7365

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Superb effort Jim.....thanks for sharing the results, and looking forward to further testing!

Great November fish by the way.....

Nice work, Jim.

I gotta say your conclusions are probably right. Too many variables, of course.
But I still like the numbers. Great results on those wicked old Gulp! baits! LOL
Im more impressed with your knowledge of the waters you're fishing. Me, I'm always guessing what's going on down there.

excellent experiment Jim;;   I have tried gulp products;; many- many times;; very little luck with them.  about to give them up!!

nice study Jim!

thanks to Gulp ... i now have two rigs stowed away in the car for just in case fishing ... oh and a jar of maggots also.

This is what I had always hoped for Gulp! - a ready bait, no fuss.
I've never had much success with them, which I attribute as much to my choice of spots as anything.

This is how it all started for me David just over 2- 1/2 years ago….. my wife and some good friends were planning an afternoon of fishing with the kids. I was to take the older boy and my son out in the boat while the women stayed behind and fished off the public docks with the younger kids, they said “NO WORMS” So on the way down I asked the guy behind Jays Sporting Goods counter what he suggested was wax worms then …. I replied nothing live or bloody. He disappeared for a second and came back with the gulp crème colored maggots.
At the docks I rigged the kids up with ice fishing rods and Spiderman outfits and gulp maggots and bobbers. I took a few practice casts and immediately started hooking 5 to 6 inchers. The women agreed everything was fine and us guys took off. Every few minutes we would here squealing and laughing from the docks. The kids were having a blast catching fish and the women were baiting the hooks! My first success story with gulp.

I think it's the northern fish.
They're just hungrier.

WORMS VS GULP!...Part II...

Fished a new pond today, a whole 1.1 miles from the house, and did some more experimenting. Here's the short version...

Caught a few nice gills and bass on untipped Sonnys Super Minnow, just to give it a test drive, more to come on that.

-Used garden worms vs. Gulp! as a tipping bait for 1/64th oz jigs and the worms took 26 gills to just 1 for the Gulp! tipped jigs. Fished the same areas, and one angler, my bro-in-law, Paul, used the Gulp! earthworms with little success. He switched to the worms and caught a half dozen.

-Most of the fish I caught were in a small corner that had some dying, yet some still green and emerging, weeds that topped out at about 3 feet from the bottom in six feet of water, I set the bobber at 3.5 feet and had the most success there, even though most casts required a little weed removal from the jig. The fish seemed to be feeding at or near the tops of the remnant weeds.

-Bluegills ran from 8 to 9.5 and most all were males. Bass were stunted and thin...standard issue for quality bluegill ponds. This remote pond gets very little fishing activity. Water about 56...would like to fish it in late May for some pre-spawn bluegill action.

So...again, no real conclusions except that the fish just wanted the real McCoy today. Well see what Saturday brings.

Paul with his best gill of the day.

Most fish took the shad dart jig with a sizable worm chunk. They seemed to like the worm squirming.

That's a mouthful

I've experienced Gulp! minnows outfishing live bait several times with gills and also crappie. The 1" are great for gills whole. I never cut them down to a smaller size. However, I'm not a huge fan of the other gulp baits...they catch fish but they're not anything special in my eyes.....

Jim were the gills loosely or tightly schooled

Ken...since this is just a small 2 acre pond I am assuming that the fish were pretty tightly schooled in specific locations due to forage availability and weed growth. We caught a few elsewhere, but the Hot Corner photo I posted produced 75% of the gills...that's where the weeds were.

RSS

Latest Activity

Slip Sinker replied to Slip Sinker's discussion FISHING THE THERMOCLINE
"Hey John Congrats on the new Helix 5 unit… great choice. What I have been finding is that a…"
1 hour ago
John Sheehan replied to Slip Sinker's discussion FISHING THE THERMOCLINE
"I have charted fish at 15-20 ' deep  that I couldn't catch at 2 lakes past two times…"
2 hours ago
Slip Sinker commented on Slip Sinker's photo
Thumbnail

20180625-Nearly forgot to post this beauty from June

"...Hey thanks FishingmadMark ! alot of fisherman dont realize for b.gills to reach the…"
2 hours ago
Slip Sinker replied to Slip Sinker's discussion FISHING THE THERMOCLINE
"...hey thanks FishingMadMark!... grew up summers on a cottage on Duck Lake in White Lake TWP...…"
2 hours ago
Slip Sinker commented on Slip Sinker's photo
Thumbnail

20180625-Nearly forgot to post this beauty from June

"...Hey thanks FishingmadMark ! "
2 hours ago
FishingmadMark commented on Slip Sinker's photo
Thumbnail

20180625-Nearly forgot to post this beauty from June

"Epic man! I know a little something about gills in SE Michigan, all I can say is…"
3 hours ago
FishingmadMark replied to Slip Sinker's discussion FISHING THE THERMOCLINE
"Hey Slip, more awesome info. Thanks. Hey, I have learned a lot here. I’ve been getting better…"
3 hours ago
Jeffrey D. Abney posted photos
6 hours ago
Jeffrey D. Abney posted a status
"Got out a couple hours this morning, dodged storms but the high winds forced me to surrender after 37 gills on shallow cover...."
7 hours ago
Jeffrey D. Abney commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
7 hours ago
Slip Sinker replied to Slip Sinker's discussion SLIP’S 2018 LOGS, STATUS AND STRATEGIES
"20180625-Late start and missed most of the Major.Period! With a couple days before the full moon at…"
10 hours ago
Slip Sinker posted a photo

20180625-Nearly forgot to post this beauty from June

Best Fish of the day at 10“ class just missing the trophy Mark!Long-Cast/.016 oz Jig/Pink Waxie
11 hours ago
Slip Sinker replied to Slip Sinker's discussion SLIP’S 2018 LOGS, STATUS AND STRATEGIES
"20180625-Late start and missed most of the Major.Period! With a couple days before the full moon at…"
11 hours ago
John Sheehan commented on John Sheehan's photo
Thumbnail

13"Crappie on a Berry!

"Jeffrey ,so the Catfish trick worked on Crappie too huh!"
14 hours ago
John Sheehan commented on John Sheehan's photo
Thumbnail

13"Crappie on a Berry!

"Went back for an hour  last evening and couldnt find one berry .Guess the Crappie climbed up…"
14 hours ago
Slip Sinker posted a photo
18 hours ago
Slip Sinker replied to Slip Sinker's discussion SLIP’S 2018 LOGS, STATUS AND STRATEGIES
"Photo library of trophies for the 2018 season! https://photos.app.goo.gl/sTLDAMEhxgVQac7v8"
19 hours ago
Slip Sinker replied to Slip Sinker's discussion SLIP’S 2018 LOGS, STATUS AND STRATEGIES
"20180722-~~<")))))><(-*Summer.Peak*--43%/80°"
19 hours ago
Slip Sinker replied to Slip Sinker's discussion SLIP’S 2018 LOGS, STATUS AND STRATEGIES
"20180621-Personal Best P.Seed at 10” Fish and Swim with Family! We got on the water after the…"
20 hours ago
Slip Sinker replied to Slip Sinker's discussion SLIP’S 2018 LOGS, STATUS AND STRATEGIES
"… … … … … … … "
20 hours ago

© 2018   Created by Bluegill.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service