Bluegill - Big Bluegill

Do you love big bluegill?

Just wondering what everyone's opinion is about how big (length or weight) a bluegill needs to be, to be considered a "TROPHY". Or how big is a "BIG" bluegill?

Views: 7414

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

To me a big bluegill is anything over 1lb- up to 2lbs. A trophy is any bluegill OVER 2lbs. Anything over 4lbs is world record territory!
I live in Northeast Michigan and the biggest gill in our area is 10 or 11 inches. I've heard of bigger ones but haven't seen them. Don Hartman.
The biggest 'gill I have caught was 10.5" and weighed right at 2lbs. I thought I had done great until my cousin caught one that was almost an inch longer. We put them in a 5 gallon bucket and they almost completely covered the bottom of it. I am on my way in the morning to try to catch another one like it only this time I want to catch it thru the ice.

I agree with some of what I've seen posted here, length is one measure of a trophy gill, however girth, weight and indeed coloration add alot to it. Where I fish in Pennsylvania an 8-inch gill is a good sized one, 10+ for a trophy and consideration given to the thicker but shorter fish. One thing I always appreciate is the coloring of the fish, next to the native brook trout the bluegill is the most colorful fish I've caught, and what a variety of colors they offer~!
Did you pet it? You know you gotta pet it! I wonder just how tuff them big gills are. I forgot about some in the live well one night! This has happened only once. A lil beer drankin got me distracted. I was intendn on puttin on Ice but after a few beers and some good conversation I forgot. Needless to say when I remembered 2 days later.....only one of almost 20 fish were dead. Heck I felt so confident that these jokers earned the rite to live after that..... I hooked the boat up and took it to the launch to meet a buddy of mine to do some dock fishin. I mixed the creek water in over the next 2 hours to keep em from goin into shock and let em all go. He asked why we fishin if you already got all them in the boat? Just bait your hook Mark and dont ask stupid questions cause they always gonna lead to a stupid answer! LOL
My thoughts on one pounders being trophies is... throw em back if your trophy fishin' if you meat fish like me...keep half the pounders and throw the rest back for spawnin. Over 11 inches and at least one and three quarter pounds is trophy material. Ten inches are commoners. But the girth is important. A short ten inch fattie that goes more than a pound and a half is a neat fish but not quite the 12 inch slot fish, and its really a bonus when a 12 inch gill is bigger around than it is long and yes in Northern Michigan this animal exists.
Today I went to Cabela's in Hoffman Estates near Chicago. I saw 3 bluegills mounted on the wall near Fly Fishing Section. WOW! 13 inch 2 lbs 10 oz monster Bluegill, Second is 12 inch 1 lbs 14 oz Bluegill and third is 10 inch 14 oz Sunfish!

Over 2 lbs is true monster and dream trophy Bluegill! 24 oz (1 1/2 lbs) is trophy Bluegill!
Over 1 pound is trophy in almost everywhere and far northern states!
Make your goal is one at a time and after catch one pound then make your next goal is 1.5 lbs and let 1 pound back to water! That would be great for big bluegills in the future!
Great Information
Lived in south Georgia where the private ponds have monster flish...I live in Minnesnota again ( my hometown ).. but I have caught alot of 9 1/2 and a scant few 10 +...those were quite common down south..
I would be as happy as a goat in a trash pile if I could find a pond with 9" average 'gills. Now, they would not be trophies, but, I fish for food (sometimes). As for where the biggies grow, my aging memory picks southern ponds. I think the record came from an experimental pond at Auburn University - somewhere around 4 lbs. It also depends on the individual properties of the habitat. Once, in Ohio, I had the honor to fish in a spring-fed pond where the owner had installed a light over the water and an automatic feeder loaded with soya bean cake broken up. I went home with 8 or 10 bluegills that averages around 10 inches. Should have released them because their flesh was "peppered" with black grub. As a fisheries biologist, I knew that cooking would kill the grubs and they were safe to eat. However, I was not quite hungry enough that time. Racoons in the nearby woods feasted that night.
I fish in the Kentucky River at Frankfort, KY and a big Gill would probably run about 8" and about 3/4 LBs here. I don't think that qualifies as a trophy, but I would be a happy camper to bring 5 or 6 of that size back to be cooked!

Jack Taylor
I have to agree with some of the guys... that a bluegill of any size caught on a fly rod is a trophy fish. Especially if you tied your offering yourself. I remember fishing a sink tip line at Bernasconi Beach one day with a little scud artificial that I tied myself... got hit in about 10 feet of water... (I was s l o w l y dragging bottom) pulled in a beautifully coloured Redear... about one pound... fought like the dickens on my 3 wt rod... thought Moby Dick was no longer Melvilles problem... I consider it a Trophy fish and a Trophy memory.

When fishing Ultra Light Gear my son Jon Jon and I consider a fish of 10 inches 1.5 Lbs to be a Trophy fish... anything over 2 lbs is a "Specimen" and we would consider to be a 'fish of a lifetime'.




Latest Activity

Jeffrey D. Abney commented on Bob Gaines's photo

Lake Perris, CA

"Awesome fish and picture Bob!"
14 hours ago
John Sheehan commented on Bob Gaines's photo

Lake Perris, CA

"Great Fish and Pic Bob !"
15 hours ago
John Sheehan commented on DAVID L EITUTIS's status
"Tooty !How the Hell are ya? Catchin 'Biguns and finding quality Classic Gear I hope!"
15 hours ago
John M. Grimes replied to Smoltz's discussion Full moon and the spawn?
"  I know I'm late to this discussion, but we fished yesterday 8/6/2020, 3 days after the…"
DAVID L EITUTIS posted a status
Bob Gaines posted a photo

Lake Perris, CA

This coppernose measured just over 11 inches. Catch and release form my float tube.
John Sheehan commented on John Sheehan's group Slip Floating
"Welcome Dave Schuyler !"
dave schuyler joined John Sheehan's group

Slip Floating

Last year (2009)was the first year slip floating for me and found it to be very effective.Would…See More
John Sheehan posted photos
John Sheehan left a comment for Marvin Morgan
"My Pleasure Marvin .I have learned a lot in the past 11 years since I've been on this site…"
Jul 29
Marvin Morgan joined John Sheehan's group

Slip Floating

Last year (2009)was the first year slip floating for me and found it to be very effective.Would…See More
Jul 28
Marvin Morgan left a comment for John Sheehan
"John, Thanks so much for the helpful info that you passed along to me....I appreciate your help.…"
Jul 28
John Sheehan commented on Marvin Morgan's blog post How to properly rig slip/fixed thill floats
"Checkout this Group here Marvin .Hopefully you glean what info you need from the activity there…"
Jul 28
Marvin Morgan posted a blog post

How to properly rig slip/fixed thill floats

While I prefer using slip floats, I would like to know how to properly rig both the slip and fixed…See More
Jul 27
John Sheehan posted photos
Jul 25
John Sheehan commented on John Sheehan's photo


"What we refer to as a Pumpkinseed ."
Jul 23
John Sheehan replied to chris's discussion favorite lures in the group pickerel fishermen
"4" Easy Shiner Swim bait kicks Butt retrieved slowly near bottom in 20-15' .Working great…"
Jul 20
John Sheehan commented on Josh Neugebauer's group Bass Fishing
"BBOTY so far; 19.5" 4,1/4 # Grabbed a 4" Swimbait .A deep late June  Fish…"
Jul 20
John Sheehan commented on chris's group pickerel fishermen
"Caught in mid July 26.5" ,4#9 oz.Pickerel BOTY so far"
Jul 20
John Sheehan commented on Sam k.'s group Trout Bums
"Grabbed a 4" Swimbait back in early May in around 13-7 fow."
Jul 20

© 2020   Created by Bluegill.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service