Bluegill - Big Bluegill

Do you love big bluegill?

Ladies and Gentleman: I see lots of pictures of large (trophy?) gills. I hope and pray that they arent being kept. They should be treated just like a trophy Bass,Pike, etc.They do more good when returned to the pond, lake,stream..living to be caught and enjoyed another day. If you must keep for a meal consider the smaller ones which in turn leaves room to produce more "trophy" gills.

Views: 405

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

I do agree that most trophy bluegill should be released but I have never caught one that was super big but I would like to mount one
I subscribe to returnin trophy size fish of any breed back to the water.
Can anyone tell me what would be considered a trophy size gill in central michigan?
Thanks, Everyone
I was going to give my thoughts on the subject... then I read Dr. Bruce's reply and all I can say is "DITTO"

Tight Lines
Rob
Thank you, but I would like to do a tiny bit of rephrasing.

I think that releasing larger bluegill is a really crucial part of creating fisheries that produce big individuals. I practice it, and I recommend it....I just try not to preach it. ;-)

It seems like people that feel "preached" to, don't tend to be influenced much. But when you take a friendly, and patient approach, then people's stances will soften.

What's the old saying?......Something like attracting something or other with honey and not vinegar?..... Can't quite remember.
I suppose I will weigh in a little bit. All I could ever ask any fisherman of any species is to be a good stewart of what we have. The DNR doesn't have it all figured out yet. A good example here in Mn is they are finding that curtain slot limits and stocking practices cannot be a blanket requirement on all the lakes, it has to be treated on a lake by lake basis. There are to many lakes (or eco systems) for them to figure out the perfect scenerio for each species (that could change in time). So as responsible fisherman we should get to know our area lakes well enough to develop good harvesting practices for that lake. Then educate people as the opportunities arise. If we all practice what we preach, the results will soon start to show. Maybe in time we will have the best of both worlds, good harvestability with some tropheys thrown in.
Exactly what Bruce stated......DITTO
I know two lakes is not far from my home ( less than one hour drive) is catch and release only! So far no trophy bluegills! Maybe somewhere in the lake but I don't know! I think something to do with shad! Lot of shad in both lakes might cause bluegills to grow slow and limit of food!
I remember somewhere article to talk about large manmade lakes in southern states have poor bluegill fishery because of lot of shad!
All I can think of is the best way is if you catch some nice 'gills over 8 inch then let it go! It get chance to grow bigger!

For George Husted.....
I looked at my big bluegill notebook. Houghton Lake in Roscommon Co in Michigan have many bluegills over one pound! 1 lb 11 oz in 1976 and 1.5 lbs in 1977!
If you spend your time and money building your own pond for bluegills, you are responsible for the management of those fish. You decide what to keep, what to feed them, weather to feed them, who will be allowed to fish and so on.

In many parts of the country the only way you can have access to good bluegill fishing is to invest the time, money and energy into building your own pond. I commend those folks especially the ones who study and learn what works best and pass this information on to the rest of us.

As soon as you go to a public lake you have no obligation nor duty to make any decisions about what anybody else does except to follow the law. The decisions you make for yourself notwithstanding.

In Michigan there are ample opportunities to catch trophy bluegills without that kind of extraordinary effort, but you still have to put in your time learning how to catch them.

There are folks who believe the fishing on any particular lake, river or stream could be much better if only the fishermen would release all the big fish without regard to all the other complexities that make up trophy waters. These people in my opinion are misguided.

Catch and Release in my opinion is not a good idea. When you have a catch and release or no kill area, none of the fish are utilized. Most lakes, streams or rivers that produce trophy sized fish can be managed effectively by allowing limited numbers of fish to be kept and still be a great trophy lake.

I also believe that bluegills between 8" and 10" make better brood stock. A bluegill over 10" in my opinion is past his prime. Throwing back large bluegills might be doing nothing for the fishery so is a wasted effort. I am all for conservation, but only when it makes sense. Many times people let their emotions guide them and make moral judgements thinking that they are doing something noble when in fact they are not.

Fishermen will flock to a lake when the word gets out that the bite is on. Fish stocks will be reduced and fish will be more difficult to catch which will induce less people to fish them and the lake will recover since there is more food for the remaining fish.

As fishermen we should be careful we are promoting the right thing and not just because it sounds good. Any kind of special regulation should only be applied after the fish professionals research the lake to find out if the regulation will help the fish or just give some fishermen a warm fuzzy feeling because they think they are doing the right thing. This is especially true for fishermen who want to apply their moral beliefs on the rest of us.

No kill and flies only regulations are the worst two regulations ever designed and are self serving. They are special rules for people who believe they are entitled to them. Within ever population there are some fish that are easily caught and some average fish and some fish that are very wary making them difficult to catch. Most of these special rules are promoted by people who want others to release the easy fish so they will have a better chance to catch them

RSS

Latest Activity

Jeffrey D. Abney posted a status
"Picked up bait, boat hooked up…..up against a cold front tomorrow with my son in law Joe….hopefully we can find a few fish before the rain.."
16 hours ago
Jeffrey D. Abney commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Thumbnail

My Wife’s Dinner Tonight….Buffaloed Crappie….10/12/2021

"Enjoy Mikey-D…..real tasty recipe, crappie are so good, just kicks it up a…"
yesterday
Jeffrey D. Abney replied to Frank M's discussion Never saw a fish with this deformity!
"Always cool to see the survivors…..I agree with Bruce….could have been a bird of prey…"
yesterday
Mikey-D commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Thumbnail

My Wife’s Dinner Tonight….Buffaloed Crappie….10/12/2021

"Dang Jeff that looks pretty good never tried that but seeing this think I'm going to try it…"
yesterday
Bruce Tomaselli replied to Frank M's discussion Never saw a fish with this deformity!
"I bet  a bird, heron, kingfisher, etc. took a swipe at it."
Thursday
Jeffrey D. Abney posted photos
Tuesday
Jeffrey D. Abney posted a status
"All fish cleaned…waiting out the Invest right offshore, gusting over 30 this morning, creeks down over two feet in the last 12 hours.."
Sunday
Jeffrey D. Abney posted photos
Oct 9
Jeffrey D. Abney posted photos
Oct 8
Jeffrey D. Abney posted photos
Oct 8
Jeffrey D. Abney posted photos
Oct 8
Jeffrey D. Abney posted a status
"Started a long weekend in the coastal marsh….water temps have dipped below 70 and the crappie are going shallow for the Fall feed…"
Oct 8
Jeffrey D. Abney commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Thumbnail

Dinner Tonight……10/4/2021

"Thanks John…..I thank my family for teaching me so many cultural enjoyments when it comes to…"
Oct 7
Jeffrey D. Abney commented on John Sheehan's group Piscatorial Pursuit of Perch
"Thanks, I personally love the period between 70 to 60 in the Fall as well as Spring 60 to…"
Oct 7
Jeffrey D. Abney commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Oct 7
John Sheehan commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Thumbnail

Dinner Tonight……10/4/2021

"You got it going on Jeffrey!"
Oct 7
John Sheehan commented on John Sheehan's group Piscatorial Pursuit of Perch
"YES! We got 67 degrees this past Tuesday Jeff .The outing looked perfect with overcast skies but we…"
Oct 7
DAVID L EITUTIS commented on Steve C's photo
Thumbnail

yellow perch 13.5"

"MAN that's a nice perch for sure......congrats to you"
Oct 7
DAVID L EITUTIS commented on Jeffrey D. Abney's photo
Thumbnail

Chestnut Chest Gill…..10/2/2021

"MAN THAT'S ONE PRETTY FISH JEFFREY , CONGRATS TO YOU BUDDY....."
Oct 7
DAVID L EITUTIS replied to DAVID L EITUTIS's discussion "WHAT'S IT WORTH "
"I'VE REREAD ALL THE REPLIES  AND CAME TO THE CONCLUSION  THAT ALL THE TALK JUST ADDS…"
Oct 7

© 2021   Created by Bluegill.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service