Do you love big bluegill?
Need educated
Ok guys I'm confused...imagine that! For weeks I've seen "gillcracker" pics going up and nearly everytime I think hmmmmm. Some look like plain ole gorgeous redear while others look like possible hybrids. So my question is "how do you define a gillcracker?
Views: 861
Replies to This Discussion
-
Permalink Reply by Tony Livingston on
-
I have a study SOMEWHERE regarding BG x RES hybrids...... IF I can find it, I'll post some more info!
-
-
Sorry for the delay, I FINALLY found the study I was looking for:
"HYBRIDIZATION OF FISHES IN NORTH AMERICA", family centrarchidae, by W.F. Childers.
It's here if someone would like more info:
http://www.fao.org/docrep/005/B3310E/B3310E10.htm
Basically, Childer's found that the offspring resulting from the pairing of a male Bluegill, and a female Redear, were 97% male. Interestingly enough, he obtained the same result from pairing a male Redear with a female Bluegill - 97% male offspring.
As far as these hybrids reproducing, the results appear somewhat mixed. Childer's reported no significant reproduction from the male Redear x female Bluegill hybrids, as well as very little from the male Bluegill x female Redear EXCEPT for a couple of ponds in Indiana which showed "abundant" reproduction. I'm not sure what to make of those results, as the fish were apparently stocked into ponds that contained no other fish.
My gut feeling says that the male BG x female RES combination has successfully reproduced in our ponds. Certainly they go through the motions of building and defending nests, however that is not to say they will breed "true", as I find it possible that they will backcross with another Bluegill, or Redear.
-
Permalink Reply by Jen Nayfly on
-
Thanks all! I am now educated! I know I've never caught one but it's added to my bucket list!
-
Permalink Reply by Nick Holt on
-
Okay. I've caught some gillcrackers here in Ga., and now ya'll got me curious about one thing. Are these fish a true hybrid that can't reproduce or are they just a cross breed? Either way, I do agree that they put up a good fight on 4 lb. test line and taste just as good. Nick
-
Permalink Reply by Goose Pond Monster on
-
There are a few of these in my father-in-law's buddy's pond. I knew they were some kind of hybrid and I am not happy to know they have a name.
-
-
- ‹ Previous
- 1
- 2
- Next ›
Latest Activity
cupsaw bass
"The Yellow Perch Pattern is more so a Northern catcher I believe, Jeff. The Silver /Black Back and…"
"Scattered thunderstorms predawn moved out to sea and I gave it a shot..North Carolina creeks/river were very dirty from runoff, moved north"
"Hoping the beat the frontal boundary tomorrow morning for a crappie stalk on the coastal marsh….we have a lot of uncertainty in our weather"
cupsawlow waterwalleye
"Nice adjustment to the conditions John……good fishing…..cool that you tied the…"
cupsawlow waterwalleye
"Hey Jeff-Every 4 years or so the lake committee lowers the lake for folks to do dock repairs. Thats…"
cupsawlow waterwalleye
"In a drought or drawdown for damn work? Nice fish…..I’ve never caught one but always…"
cupsaw bass
"I loved this bait color as a child…..but after lots of torture from being out fished by my…"
"Finally got a calm morning on the 19 day of September, a coastal low dumped rain and high winds promising to turn the marsh over and it did."
"Very rough weather pattern, ready to get out if the wind will break…all the creeks are blown out and holding low….had a good dinner tonight…"
© 2025 Created by Bluegill.
Powered by
