Bluegill - Big Bluegill

Do you love big bluegill?

Hey everyone hope you all are great fishing season and enjoying the summer, unfortunately at my pond the fish are not doing all that great this summer. My pond has always produced 4 to 5 pound bass as well as a good population of 9-10 inch fat bluegills but, this summer is a different story. The biggest bass that i have been catching are 15-16 inchers and are pretty dang skinny, and the bluegill seem to be skinnier in the shoulders as well. We have always been on top of taking out fish regularly so i am not sure if overpopulation is the problem. Any ideas or suggestions would be great! Thanks

Views: 1360

Replies to This Discussion

Are there any other species in the pond?  Do you feed?  How many fish of each species do you keep per year?  Is there weedgrowth in the pond?  

yes, there are black crappie and a small amount of channel cats, there are also carp which we have been trying to eliminate for years but have been unsuccessful. We have not been keeping exact count on the number of fish that have been coming out but we usually keep 15 fish(mostly bluegill) every 1-2 weeks. Any bluegill, bass, and channel that looks skinny and unhealthy we throw onto the bank, because some are even to skinny to filet! We do not feed because it is simply just not in the budget. And this year we have lot of thick weed grow in the shallows, more than in recent years. By the way, this is a 6 acre pond with 25 feet of water. Also, im thinking that with the drought we are having in Illinois and the extreme heat, that high water temps and the low pond level might be effecting the fish. What do you think?

Thanks, Wade

 

Are they common carp or grass carp?  Grass carp will eventually die out if they're not re-stocked, but common carp are prolific spawners and can decimate a food chain.  If you have common carp in the pond, they can be a big problem.  You could try stocking some flathead catfish in the 5-10 lb. range, if you can source them (I could get you some if you were in this area), and if a lot of the carp are under 14" the flatheads might eventually thin them out - this approach has been used successfully by a couple state DNRs in the past - but if there are a lot of large carp, you'll have a hard time getting ahead of them.  What kind of carp are they and how numerous are they?

Is your goal for the pond big bass or big bluegill?  It's nearly impossible to have both in the same pond, as the ideal conditions for one are the worst for the other and vice versa.  If you're after big bluegill, you may be keeping too many per year out of that size pond, especially if you're keeping the larger ones.  It takes a few years in your neck of the woods for a bluegill to reach 8", so if you regularly take out the larger ones, over time you can remove all of them (the big ones) and the remaining fish never have a chance to get big before being caught out.  And, a study done in 2001 by Illinois fisheries biologists found that removing large male bluegill from a population can permanently damage the genetics of the entire population.  The right amount of harvest is good, and can make a big difference in how big your bluegill (or any species) ultimately get; but if you overdo it, you can kill the genetics of the population.  

It sounds like you may have simply harvested too many of the bigger bluegill.  Keep the intermediate ones - 7" and under - and release any bluegill over 7".  If bluegill are your main focus, releasing all bass that you catch will help greatly, as the small bass will become more numerous and will keep the smaller bluegill thinned out so that the fish that survive have more food and get much larger.

The extra weedgrowth makes it more difficult for the bass to prey on small bluegill, which not only can give the bass less food, but can also result in more small bluegill, which compete with the larger bluegill for food.  Weedgrowth should be kept to a minimum if the goal is big bluegill.  

Lower water means less carrying capacity for the pond - less total food in the food chain, resulting in more competition and slowed growth.  

They are common carp and they have been in the pond since the pond was made which was over 40 years ago. When the carp were going crazy spawning this spring all we saw were 6 or so large carp thrashing around in the shallows and this was the only commotion we could see around the pond. This leads me to believe that there may not be too many carp in the pond. Large numbers of carp are known to create turbid waters, and almost always the water is fairly clear to very clear. How about tiger musky for the carp?

My pond has always been known to produce large bluegill (9-10 inchers). We always let go the larger ones and we are careful about not taking those big bulls. We keep only the bluegill under 8 inches. Because we ultimately want a big bluegill pond. It isnt like the 8 to 9 inchers are gone, but instead they are just very skinny, this makes me think that we simply have to many mouths and not enough food. And one more thing, we have been noticing these little leeches in the mouths of our bluegill and bass, could this be a problem? Or could these fish be diseased?

 

The creatures in the fishes' mouths could be some kind of parasite, which would not have a positive effect on the fish.  I would suggest contacting a state fisheries biologist to come out and look at whatever critters are in their mouths.  Hopefully he can identify what you have, and give recommendations as to remedies.  

If big bluegill are your focus, don't keep any bass, at all.  

Common carp are bad, bad.  If you have a few you likely have a bunch.  You might think about having someone electroshock the pond just to see how many carp are in there because if there are significant numbers of them they'll take a lot of food away from your bluegill.  Tiger muskie would definitely eat them, if the carp are small enough, but you probably won't be able to source muskie larger than 14" or so, and a 14" muskie is about as big around as a very thin cigar - it would be at least a couple years before the muskie would get big enough to eat any carp more than six or eight inches long.  Whereas flathead, or blue, catfish, if you got them five pounds or larger, would be able right away to eat a one-pound carp.  

Whatever parasite is in the fish's mouth could easily be part of the problem.  Do you have a lot of snails in the pond?  If you do, stocking the largest redear you can find (so they have less chance of getting eaten) will cut down on the snails.  Snails are a host for some species of parasite.

If water quality has remained the same, then feed is an issue. Fatheads and feed could help a lot. As you probably already know if you feed the bluegill the bass will be just fine unless all the bluegill are very large.

 You said both LMB and BG were skinny,so feed/forage has to be the issue if water quality and temps are about the same as the previous years IMHO.

  Shell crackers may help take care of the parasites. I have heard Tilapia help too, by eating some of the poop and stuff like that, but should be a question for you county extention agent or local college freshwater biologist if you are that lucky.

RSS

Latest Activity

Jeffrey D. Abney commented on Bob Gaines's photo
Thumbnail

Lake Perris, CA

"Awesome fish and picture Bob!"
13 hours ago
John Sheehan commented on Bob Gaines's photo
Thumbnail

Lake Perris, CA

"Great Fish and Pic Bob !"
14 hours ago
John Sheehan commented on DAVID L EITUTIS's status
"Tooty !How the Hell are ya? Catchin 'Biguns and finding quality Classic Gear I hope!"
14 hours ago
John M. Grimes replied to Smoltz's discussion Full moon and the spawn?
"  I know I'm late to this discussion, but we fished yesterday 8/6/2020, 3 days after the…"
yesterday
DAVID L EITUTIS posted a status
"HOPE EVERYONE IS ALL RIGHT ON HERE, SORRY IT'S BEEN A WHILE SINCE I'VE BEEN ON....."
Thursday
Bob Gaines posted a photo

Lake Perris, CA

This coppernose measured just over 11 inches. Catch and release form my float tube.
Wednesday
John Sheehan commented on John Sheehan's group Slip Floating
"Welcome Dave Schuyler !"
Tuesday
dave schuyler joined John Sheehan's group
Thumbnail

Slip Floating

Last year (2009)was the first year slip floating for me and found it to be very effective.Would…See More
Monday
John Sheehan posted photos
Monday
John Sheehan left a comment for Marvin Morgan
"My Pleasure Marvin .I have learned a lot in the past 11 years since I've been on this site…"
Jul 29
Marvin Morgan joined John Sheehan's group
Thumbnail

Slip Floating

Last year (2009)was the first year slip floating for me and found it to be very effective.Would…See More
Jul 28
Marvin Morgan left a comment for John Sheehan
"John, Thanks so much for the helpful info that you passed along to me....I appreciate your help.…"
Jul 28
John Sheehan commented on Marvin Morgan's blog post How to properly rig slip/fixed thill floats
"Checkout this Group here Marvin .Hopefully you glean what info you need from the activity there…"
Jul 28
Marvin Morgan posted a blog post

How to properly rig slip/fixed thill floats

While I prefer using slip floats, I would like to know how to properly rig both the slip and fixed…See More
Jul 27
John Sheehan posted photos
Jul 25
John Sheehan commented on John Sheehan's photo
Thumbnail

IMG_E0806[1]

"What we refer to as a Pumpkinseed ."
Jul 23
John Sheehan replied to chris's discussion favorite lures in the group pickerel fishermen
"4" Easy Shiner Swim bait kicks Butt retrieved slowly near bottom in 20-15' .Working great…"
Jul 20
John Sheehan commented on Josh Neugebauer's group Bass Fishing
"BBOTY so far; 19.5" 4,1/4 # Grabbed a 4" Swimbait .A deep late June  Fish…"
Jul 20
John Sheehan commented on chris's group pickerel fishermen
"Caught in mid July 26.5" ,4#9 oz.Pickerel BOTY so far"
Jul 20
John Sheehan commented on Sam k.'s group Trout Bums
"Grabbed a 4" Swimbait back in early May in around 13-7 fow."
Jul 20

© 2020   Created by Bluegill.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service